Oscar Pistorius left the witness box
in tears twice today during a fierce line of questioning from the state
prosecutor who accused him of doctoring his testimony to fit evidence at
the scene.
'You're not using your emotional state as an escape are you?' Mr Nel said
Mr Nel also tried to pin Pistorius on whether he intended to shoot at the intruder, stating that he did not fire a warning shot. He alleged the runner changed his aim
with his 9mm pistol to ensure that he hit Reeva Steenkamp as she fell
back against a magazine rack after the first shot. (An image of the four bullet holes in the toilet door through which Pistorius shot his girlfriend seen above)
'You never gave them a chance, in your version,' Mr Nel said, building the prosecution case that Pistorius shot to kill. Please continue. This lawyer made some valid points...
|
Courtroom reconstruction of the toilet in which Miss Steenkamp was
shot. The cricket bat which the athlete used to break down the toilet
door can also be seen
|
Pistorius
said he fired four times through the closed toilet door in his home
last year after hearing a 'wood' sound that he mistook for the door
being opened by an intruder who was about to attack him.
The athlete said that, in retrospect, the noise he probably heard was the magazine holder being moved by his girlfriend.
Mr Nel said Pistorius killed Miss Steenkamp intentionally after a fight and is lying about fearing an intruder.
He
said Pistorius heard Miss Steenkamp, struck by the first shot, fall
against the magazine rack and that he used that sound to adjust his aim.
'I'm saying you heard the magazine rack and you changed your aim,' Mr Nel said to the Paralympic champion.
'I
wouldn't have heard anyone fall inside of the toilet while I was
shooting,' Pistorius replied to Mr Nel, though directing his gaze to
Judge Thokozile Masipa, who will decide on the verdict.
Pistorius said he
searched desperately for Miss Steenkamp in the dark bedroom after the
shooting, feeling across the bed, on the floor next to it and behind a
curtain before realising it might have been her in the toilet.
Mr
Nel asked Pistorius why he did not turn on the lights and also check to
see if the bedroom door was open and if Miss Steenkamp had fled that
way as gunshots had been fired.
'It's one of the things that make your version unbelievable,' Mr Nel said.
Earlier, Pistorius broke down after being asked to repeat
what he said as he moved towards the bathroom where he shot Reeva
Steenkamp after hearing a noise he thought was a burglar.
'I screamed "get the f*** out of my house",' he wailed in a high-pitched voice. Mr Nel alleged that Pistorius shouted the same words at Miss Steenkamp during a row.
|
Prosecutor Gerrie Nel |
Pistorius said he
searched desperately for Miss Steenkamp in the dark bedroom after the
shooting, feeling across the bed, on the floor next to it and behind a
curtain before realising it might have been her in the toilet.
Mr
Nel asked Pistorius why he did not turn on the lights and also check to
see if the bedroom door was open and if Miss Steenkamp had fled that
way as gunshots had been fired.
'It's one of the things that make your version unbelievable,' Mr Nel said.
Earlier, Pistorius broke down after being asked to repeat
what he said as he moved towards the bathroom where he shot Reeva
Steenkamp after hearing a noise he thought was a burglar.
'I screamed "get the f*** out of my house",' he wailed in a high-pitched voice. Mr Nel alleged that Pistorius shouted the same words at Miss Steenkamp during a row.
|
Investigating officer Captain Mike van Aardt (right) is asked by state
prosecutor Gerrie Nel (centre) to demonstrate the opening and closing of
the door through which Reeva Steenkamp was shot
|
Pistorius wept uncontrollably, prompting the judge to adjourn the hearing to allow him to compose himself.
After the judge left the courtroom, Pistorius stood sobbing with his body trembling and turned away from the gallery.
Mr
Nel also tried to pin Pistorius on whether he intended to shoot at the
intruder, but the 27-year-old said he did not intend to do so and that
he was terrified at the time.
'I didn't have time to think about what I wanted to do,' Pistorius said.
That prompted Mr Nel to question whether Pistorius was changing his legal strategy from 'self-defence' to 'involuntary action'.
He later said Pistorius did not fire a warning shot.
Pistorius
said that when he shot he had no idea who was behind the door, in
response to Mr Nel's remark that he did not know whether a child, an
unarmed burglar or more than one person could have been in the toilet.
'You never gave them a chance, in your version,' Mr Nel said, building the prosecution case that Pistorius shot to kill.
Proceedings
were halted on another occasion when he wept while denying that he intentionally shot his
girlfriend.
When pressed to state what his defence was, Pistorius said: 'I heard the noise and I did not have time to interpret it and fired out of fear.
Mr Nel replied: 'You know exactly what you were doing, you fired at Reeva. You fired at her.'
Fighting back tears, Pistorius cried out 'I did not fire at Reeva' - forcing the judge adjourn the hearing.
When
he returned to the stand, Mr Nel accused Pistorius of crying not out of
grief for his girlfriend, but because he was getting his testimony
confused.
'I'm going to argue that you got emotional because you got your defences mixed up,' Mr Nel claimed, saying the Olympian he had changed his account from one of self-defence to involuntary action.
Mr Nel said the only explanation for
why Miss Steenkamp was standing up against the door when she was shot
was because she had been running away from Pistorius.
'All the screams and shouts were at her,' Mr Nel said. 'She fled for her life'.
The prosecution has said Pistorius's account of a mistaken shooting is a lie.
Earlier, Mr
Nel told the court: 'Today, I'm going to prove your version of events
is untrue. That you tailored your version, concocted your story.
'Your version is so improbable that it cannot reasonably possibly be true.'
He went on to claim that Pistorius had argued with Miss Steenkamp shortly before the shooting.
'It's the state's case, Mr Pistorius, that she wanted to leave and that you weren't sleeping, you were both awake,' said Mr Nel.
'That's not correct my lady, that's untrue,' Pistorius replied softly.
'There was an argument,' Mr Nel said, drawing another denial.
The prosecutor's relentless
questioning has elicited tears and taut replies from the world-famous
double amputee, who insists he and the 29-year-old model were in a
loving relationship.
Mr
Nel also complained that Pistorius was being evasive and challenged him:
'Today I pick up you're not sure about things, is anything wrong?' Nel
asked. 'You're fine?'
Pistorius
grew increasingly restless during the morning, wiping his face, pinching
the bridge of his nose and clenching his jaw.
Later,
Mr Nel accused Pistorius of being a stickler for detail on some
matters, in contrast to his frequent statements in court that he could
not remember aspects of his evidence.
Mr
Nel noted that Pistorius earlier said he warned Ms Steenkamp to call
police about an intruder in a whisper, contradicting later evidence that
he spoke in a 'low tone'.
The
prosecutor also said blood spatter evidence indicated that the
athlete's statement about the location of a duvet in the bedroom was
false.
Pistorius has said
the duvet was on the bed and that police photographs of the bed cover on
the floor suggest that police moved it there after the shooting.
Mr Nel said a pattern of blood drops
on the duvet and on the carpet nearby show that it was on the floor
before police arrived, and that its location amounts to evidence that
the couple had been having an argument.
The
prosecutor also alleged that Miss Steenkamp was in the process of
getting dressed in the midst of the night-time argument and wanted to
leave Pistorius's house shortly before the shooting.
A
pair of jeans strewn on the bedroom floor showed Miss Steenkamp was
putting them on, Mr Nel said, and contrasted with her character as a
neat person who would not leave clothes lying around.
Pistorius
responded that Miss Steenkamp was neat, but he said the jeans were inside
out and therefore showed that Miss Steenkamp had not been in the process
of donning them.
Mr Nel also
questioned why the athlete did not give fuller details of his account
in his bail statement last February, days after he killed Miss
Steenkamp.
Pistorius
had said then that there was a noise from the bathroom that caused him
to think that people had broken into his house, but did not explain
until later that it was the bathroom window sliding across and slamming
against the frame.
The
athlete said on Monday that he was on medication and traumatised while
in a jail cell at the time of his bail statement, which could account
for any discrepancies with his later evidence.
Mr
Nel also said it was improbable that, in Pistorius's story, Miss
Steenkamp did not ask him why he was getting out of bed in the middle of
the night to retrieve fans from the edge of the balcony.
Culled from UK Daily Mail
83 comments:
They should just forget about if its intentional or not, he killed his girlfriend, he should be punished for that
Your comment will be visible after approval
Crazy ass drama #bright bravo#
ENOUGH OF ALL THIS CROCODILE TEARS! HE KILLED HER ON PURPOSE FULLSTOP!
Linda go to bed.
👈See all this wahala na wash, pistorius should please use his church mind and confess abeg
🔥that's just AY'S vlog sees it✌️
This case is something else. Its a really tough one for Oscar. Chei! I have been following this trial since day two, listening to every detail as events are unfolding. I dont think that Oscar will get away with this oh. But lets be watching...Thokozile will decide. Reeva family ndoo nu. May the Lord comfort u pipo
The trial is getting more and more intriguing.
Why are they wasting time w ith this pistorious guy? Too much loopholes in his story.Not even his crocodile tears and seeming remorsefulness can save his frigging white ass.His arrival as a guest in prison or grave is long overdue
God help this man o if he is telling the truth..things don't look too good for him at the moment...yet it doesn't mean he is lieing..people choose different ways of reacting to situations and yes his actions were not normal but who defines "normal"?..
May the good Lord intervene and justice prevail...
Only God knows the truth....but I pity oscar
This man can't win this case
Typical of a man who has no sense of security and very possessive. Oscar just open up and say the truth because its obvious you are a bloody liar. May God give his judgement on you speedily, murderer.
This guy ιƨ implicating himself the more. He should accept this and slack himself some little respect. I patiently watched this liar today SMH! Same justice we plead for the ALUU4.
Another day, another day of lies! The prosecutor 'nailed' him with some brutal questions and facts. Tears of guilty!
John Grisham noted in his author's note for 'A Time to Kill' that there is more drama in courtrooms than we see in every day lives. In the quest for fair hearing and reasonable doubt...I wish Nigerian legal and penal systems can someday redeem itselves.
Lets just wait and see the end of this..
Na wa o!!!
This bitch ass nigga oscar pistorius is a murderer. Period.
Abegi! One person die,dem jus dey make plenty noise. Hundreds of people are dying in our country almost everyday and no one is this serious......
Am certainly sure he's a liar trying to build up his lies but no sinner will go unpunished and I believe nemesis would catch up on him. 'HE KILLED HIS WIFE'
Taking the stand...thts what to expect; every question reminds him of jail.....hahahaha
There's no way he can explain/justify what happened that morning and not implicate himself. His version of how it happened is highly improbable *in Nel's voice*.
He made a very big mistake by even going to trial, but hey, he felt confident he stood a chance considering his theory of SAPS tampering with the crime scene.
He would have just made a deal with the state, accept the responsibility without wasting the time and resources of the state and his; that could have gotten him like 20yrs max..and that will give some sort of closure to the Steenkamps.
How can one kill a fellow and get away with it? ...Oh well, he feels he can/should!
* My R1.50c comment *
Send dis fucking nigga to jail
This guy can't escape jail. I pity him though, dunno y I feel he didn't kill her intentionally. Sentiments maybe. RIP Reeva.
i dnt seee an escape root for u @ oscar. sowie
This case is becoming tough though
He'd def b found guilty
~D great anonymous!
Dis evidence is enough IMO....Pistorios is GUILTY!
Ds guy is so full of drama,is very obvious that he killed her,he's just making up different stories!!! He should be sentenced already jare.RIP Miss Steenkamp
Dat prosecutor is good
Linda, pls always edit b4 bring it here. So much repetition. Boring story!
Such an intelligent lawyer. Wooow
He has killed her and he has killed her. The Judge will likely not convict him of murder. He should be sued to his last peeny and made completely worthless and useless...let him agree to that as his penance for taking a life...
Abeg,e nor concern me.
Apart from the fact that there was a body and a gun, the rest of this case is built on supposition.
This guy is guilty of premeditated murder.
I just hope he is found guilty.
Oscar d fine boi lol,pele..there r lots of violence in south africa nd lots of deaths unaccounted for, pistorius I pity u o bt u will end in jail, u wd av gone to apologise to reeva's parents lastyr after her death bt u choose to apologise in court
First and foremost... as a legal practitioner in the federal republic of Nigeria this is how a court room criminal examination should look like...proving all of its facts beyond reasonable doubt...having all the evidence in the court room(including construction of toilet doors with the bullet holes and toilet and baseball bat) which is in contrast with what is applicable here in Nigeria. what we have is all proceeding papers and tendered evidence if things are even tendered at all and rather than being the general principle that.. "a man is innocent until proven guilty ..it is a man is guilty until proven innocent". we are not there yet.
Mr Nel(prosecution counsel) makes a lot of sense when he stated that pistorius did not give a warning shot meaning he intended to kill.... but this is a warning sign that proving the intention of man is a hard nut to crack cos even the devil does not know the intention of man.
Its only God that knows what happened that night,this guy is growing annoying everyday.
Wow..its bcoming more glaring..these sportsmen shaa...one Oscar(chelsea)deserves an Oscar 4 diving...anoda Oscar deserves an Oscar 4 lying Α̲̅πϑ crying(acting)...2 M̶̲̥̅ε̲̣̣̣̥ prolly dropped her intentionally..too many loop-holes in his story...#Johannezboy
I just don't believe this guy. I think he was so angry at the time he wasn't thinking about the consequences. He intentionally killed her jare.
oh boy...the lawyer know book dieee! I'm just waiting 4 the last straw that'll break the camel's back. I'm certain Oscar will scream the truth out of anger.
thats not what he said linda...make your findings properly first na....He was actually shouting 'get the fuck out of my house' so if there was any intruder...it was said to the supposed intruder not reeva
The accused (Olympian) is a hell of a liar. OMG!!! It was a well composed lie but I guess he forgot that he was speaking to a lawyer.
not looking good for my guy at all , he should just admit he killed her, deep down, he flipped out and killed her bcos she was cheating
Did oscar really fired the shot to kill his girlfrnd?
There's what we call a warning shot. Self defence allows u to fire a warning shot to ascertain who d 'intruder' really is. Dat u fired four shots repeatedly without been sure of d person. Its hard to believe he fired four shots out of fear.
If he fired intentionally to kill his GF then prison is ur home for life.
What a lesson for all
Mr Nel plz Pin em well coz he cnt kill nd go free...... So luv diz case
Ahh God in heaven .... Things dat happen ,soo alarming u wud wonder wot goes on in some heads ! #ur own girlfriend dat felt so comfy as to be wt u in ur own house.. Not fair at all Pistorius
This story is gettin interesting o, nollywood scrip writrs take note
If only We cud see a video Of Wat transpired Dat nyt. . It wil All Be ova . . Macky Was hia
Mr Nel is so intelligent dat Oscar will Ave nothing 2 do but 2 come out wit d truth,dat he intentionally killed his gf.
This guy should be hung already. Good one Nel
Wonder why the delay to nail this guy.. It's obvious he killed her intentionally..
Based on this article, case closed in advance. I can presumably say Oscar Pistorious murdered Reeva Steenkamp intentionally.
I think all this stories, is meant to teach us lesson. DON'T TALK ANYHOW
okkkk, let me test my luck
CAN YOU ROCK THIS? LADIES?
When will naija courtroom ever be like this?
This guy is a bloody lair, he killed the poor girl in cold blood. Case closed
Hmmmm so serious. The worst mistake u can make is to date or marry a disable, their always heartless. They see everything as disrespect to them. God have mercy
Dangerous man
He shouldn't have killed her
GUILTY AS CHARGED!!!
even though i like the way Nel tackles him in court lets think out of the situation. Most of us react worse under intense pressure. Being a paralytic there is more vulnerability and fear. Some of you wake up with so much fear you can do anything. I heard a story once about a girl who came home from school to surprise her parents. she hid in the closet her dad heard noises, went into her room with his gun, as she busted out of the wardrobe to hug him he blew her away with his gun. ONLY CHILD O... That's what happens when fear takes over. Oscar may be lieing but it may be because he was afraid. He ALSO has anger issues as well when in a fit of rage anything can happen. Lesson: ANGER RESTS IN THE BOSOM OF FOOLS.
@Moyosore Gucci you see you SHE WAS HIS GIRLFRIEND, NOT WIFE...mumu i must comment.
God will expose you if you really did it...
Great ! New Paying Site
Many ways of earning,Instant cashout.Don't miss.
http://Youthweeklypay.com/?invite=49532
I must confess dat dis Mr Nel is one hell of a prosecutor. I mean, he is good. Good to d extent dat he'd force d truth out of a liar's mouth. Oscar, just say d truth already nd stop wastin ur time, dis case is not to ur favour
why is this case so long they should send this guy to a jail and stop wasting time.JUSTICE DELAYED IS JUSTICE DENIED!!!!!!! the guy is a killer celeb!!!
He's guilty joor he's story is two faced the Prosecutor is right
I think this idiot should plead guilty and get a lighter sentence. He knows he killed her all this rigmarole is bullshit!! He even has a new girlfriend. Sick as m&** f#*&ker
No problem, Mr Nel is there t handle d case, I knw Oscar can nt go unpurnished........
Oscar cnt go unpurnished......
Actually they need to ascertain what his intentions were on the night of the killing. That will make a different between man slaughter or first degree murder. 3 year vs 20 years in prison.
hmmmmmm what baffles me is how such a pretty girl decides to date a leg less idiot like u, fine u nor fine money may be small she could av dated bigger boys alright I get it I know you will say its love which kind love? mschew I beg my love wear double lense. I hope others learn from this. these men are not worth the troubles
A good justice from someone like this could save hundreds and thousands of lives...dat's the irony of life
A twist in the tale.
#gbam
He obviously shot her in a fit of rage n immediately regreted his action. He needs anger management therapy even in prison cos he sure won't get outta this one!
Yea, soo annoying. I used to think he was innocent but recently, his story isn't adding up. Sad tho
I know we are not supposed to judge, but Oscar Pistorius is coming across as unbelievable. He can't keep his story straight, the crying, vomiting, isn't impressing anyone. His problem is anger. She was going to leave him out of fear. That is evident from the messages she sent to him. He wasn't going to let her go, how dare she leave him, he was famous, a medal winner, she was his property. No good burglar would allow himself to be locked in a bathroom. How would he escape if caught? Also, this residence has motion detectors and burglar alarms installed. The perp would have to be hiding, else that person would have tripped the alarms.The sad part of this, I honestly believe he knew she was in the bathroom. His vanity wasn't going to let her leave, he knew he'd kill her, and now he isn't man enough to admit he did it and take his punishment. My prayers to her family, parents aren't supposed to bury their children, it's the other way round. There is nothing to take the pain away, time will dull it, but the loss will always be there. No one wins in this story, no one.
As you said the father didn't know she was even in the house at all but oscar knew reeva was in the house so they are different scenerios pls
NIL is doing a good job and from all indication things are falling apart for oscar
NIL is doing a good job and from all indication things are falling apart for oscar
Mr Nel is a firecracker... SMH this is really making me change my mind about owning a gun when I have a house. I wouldn't want any "mistakes" but knives are just the same
...The issue though is: Oscar has realised how bad the situation has gotten after killing her, before killing her his anger allowed him to take her life mercilessly without weighing precautions - THINK BEFORE YOU ACT the fact is he killed her, Murder or manslaughter he should just go and start his jail term and be repenting in God there not to people..
Vote Onyx Godwin : http://nigerianidol.com/grabthemic4_1.php
Onyx Ihope you also use that voice to praise God - It must not go to waste
Yes, Reeva is dead... R.I.P and its so painful. As for whether Oscar killed her intentionally or by mistake is only known to just three people... Oscar, God and Devil. But will throwing him into jail bring Reeva back to life? Remember, there is no justice in court. The man with more facts and evidences goes home with smiles. God help Oscar though.
Post a Comment