Rachel Canning (left) turned up to Morris County Court, New Jersey, yesterday dressed in her school uniform and pearls for the first hearing in her sensational case against her parents (right) who she claimed 'abandoned' her and owe her money. But her hopes were dampened when Judge Peter Bogaard read an expletive-laden and vicious answerphone message left by Rachel, from Lincoln Park, New Jersey, to her mother, Elizabeth, and said: 'Have you ever in your experience seen such gross disrespect for a parent? I don't see it in my house.'
Rachel with her dad and mum when the going was good
Rachel, who is suing her parents for 'abandoning' her has made sensational claims that her mom calling her 'fat' and 'porky' led to her suffering bulimia and that her former police chief father dad used to get her drunk and kiss her inappropriately. The judge denied any immediate claim for cash and adjourned to a later date - but warned her there appeared to be insufficient evidence to support her claims so far.
The judge added: 'what is the next step...are we going to open the gates for a 12-year-old to sue for an Xbox, a 13-year-old to sue for an iPhone... what about a 15-year-old asking for a 60 inch TV?' Her mother and father, Sean, broke down in court as details of how their family was torn apart were read out.
The judge today blasted Rachel for being disrespectful to her parents. When Judge Peter Bogaard read an expletive-laden and vicious answerphone message left by Rachel to her mother, Elizabeth, in which the girl said: 'I wanna s*** all over your face', he said: 'Have you ever in your experience seen such gross disrespect for a parent? I don’t see it in my house.’
The judge, sitting at Morris County court added that Rachel had given her mom and dad, Sean: ‘The proverbial f you’. He also warned he must consider the 'slippery slope' where 'we open the gates for a 12-year-old to sue for an Xbox, a 13-year-old to sue for an iPhone… what about a 15-year-old asking for a 60 inch TV?'
Rachel, who is suing her parents for ‘abandoning’ her has made sensational claims that her mom calling her ‘fat’ and ‘porky’ led to her suffering bulimia and that her former police chief father dad used to get her drunk and kiss her inappropriately.
In shocking legal documents submitted to the court, the honor-roll student said her parents’ behavior contributed to her developing an eating disorder at a young age and saw her weight plummet down to 92 pounds.
Rachel, who has two younger sisters moved in with the parents’ of a friend and is now suing for child support, medical bills, college expenses and legal fees.
She states that her parents have a combined yearly income of between $250,000 and $300,000 and she is entitled to $654-a-week in child support. Her parents have also refused to pay $6,000 owed in school fees for her Catholic High School.
Her parents claim their daughter ran off to stay with friends when she turned 18 because she refused to abide by rules they had set down, including to stop dating her boyfriend.
But today the judge clearly took a dim view of the lawsuit. He said: ‘What kind of parents would the Canning’s be if they didn’t try to set down some strict rules?
‘I’m not going to put myself in anyone’s shoes, he’s (father Sean) trying to raise a child. It’s clear to me all the positive qualities Rachel obviously has, in terms of sports and academics, but I’m not going to step on a father for how he tries to get his child on the right tracks when she has obviously come off the tracks, to put it mildly.’
When summing up later he denied all immediate financial claims, including monthly maintenance, private school payments and legal fees.
Summing up, Judge Bogaard said: ‘The court was called upon to find whether immediate financial relief was needed… It is not necessary….
‘Counsel, also needs to ask themselves, what is the next step…. Are we going to open the gates for a 12-year-old to sue for an Xbox, a 13-year-old to sue for an iPhone… what about a 15-year-old asking for a 60 inch TV….
‘I want both counsels to think of the potential slippery slope here.’
He added: ‘I think everyone needs to take a step back and realize this family and Rachel in particular is well worth the effort to salvage or attempt to.
Source: Daily Mail
That's their own culture.
ReplyDeleteif is were i come frm #proudly9ja....my mum would ask two hefty guys in the court room to carry her hands and leg she gon be floged so hard even the judge no go yarn anytin stupid gal
DeleteIf u havn't walked in someone's shoes, u have no right to call her spoilt. This judge is biased. Bringing sentiments into this case cos dey re her parents is so wrong. Y not look @ d facts of her case? Did she in anywy ask for luxuries (car, designers n co)?. This kid is asking for her tuition and medical bills. Some parents are rly not it. Sentiments just wont allow pple see the pains of this girl that actually made her go to court. One thng is certain, no matter the general public throwing her brimestones, her parents will forevr live with d heartache of whatvr personal pain they must've caused this girl to make her cry out.
DeleteB4 any1 cmes preaching, yes i know my bible and all the 'respect ur parents'. But dt dsnt give parents the right to mistreat a child. Correct them with love and not forcing ur ways into them. The kid however should hv sought extended family help rather than court. But it's a pity whites got no time for extended family bull shit. I jst pray God guards her and probably helps her get 'students loan' or stuffs like dt.
@Objective point'f U r the most useless person I've even come across. Ma guess is that u r single u don't know what it means to bear a child.
DeleteBefore you start preaching objective, the parents obligations to her ended when she clocked 18. Any thing they decide to do for her thereafter is just grace and not a right, so her being exceedingly disrespectful of them and still expecting them to cover her expenses, she is definitely crazy. If you cannot respect someone or listen to them then you do not need their money. You are 18. An adult. Take care of yourself. This is the reason child support payments end even for fathers when the child turns 18.
DeleteObjective you really need to shut the hell up,what rule is too hard for an 18yr old to obey......like my father will say "a big boy/girl is one who can afford to settle their bills so the moment you feel you're now too big to obey his rules,you move out for him and start fending for yourself coz you can't give him conditions in his own house finish" the girl had better start having a rethink coz I don't think that judge is ruling in her favor lobatan
Delete@ objective point'f may your child turn out to be this girl and may they drag your name , in the mud fool. Do you even have a child? Do you know how to mold an individual to an acceptable social standard? What wrong did they do other than to make rules in their own house for their children to follow and become responsible? How is it right that a girl comes out in public in order to win sentiments, tell the world her father touches her inappropriately and tells the mom she'd shit on her face? Is anybody deserving of a child who exhibits total lack of morals in this way? Most importantly, do you deserve a child like this? Please engage your brain next time before you write.
DeleteLmao @ d 'preachers association of the world' tearing body on top my opinion... mtschewww. So these are the so called parents????? With mumu, idiot n curses flying around. Spineless beings dt must follow follow other pple's comment.
DeleteGo n die if u hate my opinion. I've got no time for sentiments. Myopic brains that didnt see where d kid said her dad gets her drunk n touches her inappropriately n her mum calls her fat.
Little wonder many kids go through series of parental abuse (esp rape 4m fathers) and die in silence for fear'f wt the world will say. God'll will judge all u bigots who abuse ur kids n await public pity.
And for the ill mannered anon dt talked about my kids, i am so sorry to dissappoint u cos i have no intntion of imposing myself on my kids and they cannever go all out on me cos i cant deny them wt i know dey honestly deserve and i have it.
This kids parents will surely answer to God and will forever live with their conscience if they actually hurt this kid and are lying on public pity pretentiously. And if the kid herself is lying on them, she will also pay for it in due time.
In an attempt to feel among, you just made a complete fool of yourself. Being liberal and open-minded is not a ticket for such lack of restraint in thinking! I hope you can proudly show your kids these comments of yours and enjoy them suing you whilst making your home a thorn field for you. Thank you!
Deleteall deze children self... seems dey r on cheap drugz
ReplyDeleteDat Judge is good, I must say
DeleteIf it was in nigeria am sure d judge will call a meeting of combined judges and they flog d dead hell out of her. Am sure dey shud follow d nigerian way this time, it will pay off wellemly
Deletehaaa oh my God, this is the disadvantage of "oyibonism". sincerely nice upbringing with cane all along would have prevented this
ReplyDeleteNwata ojoo! (Bad child!)
ReplyDeleteWooow I admire the judge's decision and statements "should we open the door for a 12years old to sue her parents for an Xbox"
ReplyDelete~BONARIO~says so via NOKIA3310
i no fit laugh agagin.. so funny. hahahahhahah, Oyinbo children get mind o.. make she come try it for Nigeria na, if the judge wont insult her.. next please
ReplyDeleteThe judge is right. If they grant d girl her wish, parents would become afraid to set down rules for their kids and dis is part of training. And soon 10yr olds will be suing their parents for not buying them a PS game. *rme*
ReplyDeleteAre u kiddin me una see shay oyinbo dnt belief in discipline let a Nigerian child try dis nonsense she or he might not leave 2 tell d tale . She's spoilt rotten
ReplyDelete*****A-BELLE******
I so love the judge ....Omo ale!!!
ReplyDeleteThings r happening... shuuu!
ReplyDeleteI do not know what is wrong with children in this age.
ReplyDeleteIf my mother slaps an eye of that girl she will see stars.
Ride on judge...
Its only in whiteman country that bullshits like this happen.Kids are taking their right way too far.episodes of hot slaps courtesy of moi will bring such a spoilt brat to her senses.what nonsense!
ReplyDeleteAm impressed with this judge. This is sound judgement, no doubt.
ReplyDeleteThe judge is black in white skin#brilliant# I just love d judge. All dis spoilt kids abroad may God help their parents, kip waiting for child support o. Ewu
ReplyDeleteSpoiled brat...look at U, come nd try dis in 9ja na!...U will know that Blood is thicker than water
ReplyDelete~Beautiful Lopez~
Dat judge is really wise!how dare u sue ur parents 4 abandoning u wen u initially ran away frm home !and to worsen situation ur an adult !u shud b in yaba left n stay wit my dad 4 jst a week...
ReplyDeleteOloshi, so ur dad is in yaba left? No wonder. Buh I still dey wait u 4 dat oda side.
DeleteWhy are you calling him Oloshi? He indirectly means his dad will discipline the girl......you people are terrible honestly. Sad!
DeleteSo bad of her!
ReplyDeleteSorry 4 d parents
Nothing is wrong if parents wna set some rules for their kids to live by. Its their God given responsibility to look after you morally and otherwise. If you don't want those rules and wna live by yourself, then you are ready to take other responsibilities off them.
ReplyDeletespoil brat, but I don't blame her anywhere cause America u made the rules so haw deal withit
ReplyDeleteOmo komo ....
ReplyDeletethat's what happens in a place were a child can easily call the cops on the parents
ReplyDelete#milito da great#
that's what happens in a place were a child can easily call the cops on the parents
ReplyDelete#milito da great#
If it was in Nigeria she'd be in cell now reaping the benefits of her lawsuit!
ReplyDeleteImagine say this pikin do this type of thing for naija, i swear her life will never remain the same...
ReplyDelete.
.
.
***CURRENTLY IN JUPITER***
See her wicked face!!!! Spoilt brat.
ReplyDeleteI am speechless! This case will not even be attended to in a Nigeria court.
ReplyDeleteThis is the kind of nonsense one gets to see in the so called developed countries. Can she try this in Nigeria? Na serious beating them for use knock serious sense enter her head.....Mtcheeew seriously spoilt brat
ReplyDeleteOyinbo life style dey sweet die compare to African countries. ⌣̊┈̥-̶̯͡»̶̥♡thanks ⌣̊┈̥-̶̯͡»̶̥
ReplyDeleteSome of ds white kids are just plain crazy. sue ut parents? like WTH! come to Africa and try dat shit and u get serious spanking and a long session of deliverance.
ReplyDeletesee wahala sha wish na 9ja
ReplyDeleteLinda I don't tire for all this white stories. Why can't u just focus more on our contemporary Nigeria stories. Nowadays Ur story's are old gist. Huh.
ReplyDeleteThis isn't proper and it's can't happen here in Naija
ReplyDelete***Starman***
Are we going to leave our door open for our 12 years old, 15 years old...? O yea...nice question. Please let me help You add 8 years old and 5 years old kids. O yea...nice question.
ReplyDeleteOne unique thing You won't find among African kids is disrespect for their parents. You will know the kind of guts and courage You will gather to disrespect Your elders talk more of Your parents.
Except in cases of families that didn't start early with regards to respect, obedience, e.t.c. or families where You have an only child who everything goes his or her own way, or in a case of love/marriage matters.
Disrespect for parents or suing Your parents who dash You liver... abii You get guts???
De gal is beautiful. Linda tell her to come down 2 Nigeria. I will give her good aCcomodation and her basic needs. ***CATCH ME IF U CAN***
ReplyDeleteakukubi san she radarada... chai. waste of 9 months
ReplyDeleteFunny though, but i love the Judge's style of resolution.
ReplyDeleteSpare the rod and spoil the child na wetin american parent dey do.... Well, na dem sabi.... But i which this gal na my sister, boooy, she for mellow like really calm down....
ReplyDelete.
.
.
***CURRENTLY IN JUPITER***
See winch pikin way dem suppose sell for free. Ashe better thank her stars that her parent are not from Nigeria.
ReplyDeleteone of the reasons i love my country.................u no fit try am for naija. u wan sue ur parents? dem go give u ur birth history. mmmmssshhhhheeeewwwwww
ReplyDeleteSpoilt brat.
ReplyDeleteNgwanu, babes don wise up. Spoiled brat
ReplyDeleteIts always good to pray to God for good kids. This is y I don't support raising ones kids abroad cos the law has so made them to sue for even laws set in d home to guide d kids aright. SMH....kdp
ReplyDeleteI wish I were d judge. Instant 72 strokes of d cane everyday for 3days. Then send her 2 NIGERIA for proper trainin.
ReplyDeleteHa this kind of child can order a hitman to kill the parents. God help us in this world.
ReplyDeleteRuns like who just snatched BB in a market filled with touts... Lols.. First to comment...
ReplyDeletePhanisy says so Via BOLD 12
The girl needs some serious flogging and punishment a la Naija style. Kai!!! She's so damn spoilt!!!
ReplyDeleteNot in 9ja sha. It can't fit happen.
ReplyDeleteSpoilt brat,lol oyibo life good, I will not have Lever to stand to parents and nag talk more of
ReplyDeleteNice one, judge. I'm impressed! Rachel, go & collect one seat from SDK. Ish!
ReplyDeleteRegrets are bound to come later. Maybe when dad or mum must have passed on.
ReplyDeleteEyaa I feel the pains of her parents, na oyibo life sha
ReplyDeleteSpoilt brat,lol oyibo life good, I will not have Lever to stand to parents and nag talk more of
ReplyDeletewho born am to try such for 9ja
ReplyDeleteNothing we no go see again. ok! Am suing my parents for not being rich.lmao
ReplyDeleteKai oyimbo don spoil children... because you are 18, you move out of my fatherss house? and you dare to sue him again? infact the fear of been beaten to death will keep you in check constantly. even when you marry, and my father comes to visit you, you will be as straight as a pin. both you and your husband better behaved. ahahahaha loool
ReplyDeleteCompare with the "Pranking my African dad" clip
ReplyDeleteRUBBISH!!! TWALE TO ALL THE NIGERIAN PARENTS WHO TRAINED CHILDREN WITH IGBARUN IGBATI IGBAJU,IGBADI, AND ALL THE OTHER IGBA'S made us grow to be sensible respectful children(well not everyone)
ReplyDeleteSeriously lol
DeleteDon't know y daughters are never always grateful to their parents who had pass tru alot to raised them. **xame thing Uganda's President daughter did**......
ReplyDeleteNEKYNYMOUS said ......good radiance to bad rubbish. isi azu
ReplyDeleteShe's is really spoilt, according to psychology, the behaviour of the girl towards her parent is due to fixation because some actions were not taken when she was still small
ReplyDeletestupid girl
ReplyDeleteSpoilt IDIOT!
ReplyDeleteNEKYNYMOUS said......good radiance to bad rubbish. Isi azu
ReplyDeleteShe dey mad mke she com 9ja con do d@ 1,she go hail...
ReplyDeleteHmmm.......White kids and their messed up lives. I pity her parents.
ReplyDeleteRachel must have been influenced by bad friends (her bf inclusive). I'm sure the Nigerian court will not hear the girl's case at all.
ReplyDeleteShe is malnourished, she lacks vitamin Koboko.
ReplyDeleteThis oyinbo pikin dem get craze 4 head
ReplyDeleteVery sound comments from the judge, if this sets a precedence then parents wouldn't have grips on their kids and the essence of family values would diminish.
ReplyDeleteat 18, she's still going to high school. silly spoilt brat!
ReplyDeletecome and take money let me see ur head.
Thank God for Naija parents! mtchew!
If I hear,mehn I love my culture.imagine me sueing my parents,its not possible.may God have mercy on them white people
ReplyDeleteJustice well served
ReplyDeletelol @ anonymous koboko
ReplyDeleteKai imagine! Oyinbo ehn I taya 4 una oo! I luv ma naija! Do dat nonsense here! Whc jugde go evn listen 2 dat spoilt brat yeye case! White bitch!
ReplyDeleteIs this judge a black person by any chance? I hail him! This is what you get when you allow 'children' have their way in almost everything. How dare she sue her parents for such an insignificant matter? Shame on her. White kids need some good spanking at their formative years!
ReplyDeleteSEE THIS IS WHAT HAPPENS WHEN YOU DONT SPANK YOUR KIDS..
ReplyDeleteBRING HER TO NAIJA ALL SHE NEED NA MEMORY CARD RESET WITH ONE HOT SLAP.. FEAR NO GO GREE U TRY THID KIND SHIT FOR NAIJA COS AFTER COURT CASE WHEN YOU REACH HOUSE, MY PAPA WEY I KNOW GO DEAL WITH YOU.. SHIKENA
Mad pikin
ReplyDeleteCome nd chop naija slap so dat ur brain will reset
Na cane go solve her wahala
ReplyDeleteWell na abroad ds rubbish dey happen, I be school dropout,I no sue my parents,wetin i do be say,I struggle enter cotonou mkt,come dey do buying n selling till I enter hubby hux,God purnish devil,na over fEeding dey wori d girl n bad bf,both d parents wey she dey stay dere hux,she even dey laugh wey her parents dey cry sef,well she dey far frm home? Patty
ReplyDeleteWen I heard d news on gudmwnin america I felt like slappin some sense n2 d girl and ha frndz fada dat is askn 4 $13k as legal fees wtout representin d girl in court is a big goat
ReplyDeleteTombs up judge you do well. Abi like say dis judge don stay for Naija small unlike the onyimbo wey we know go juz rule in her no minding that her parent have their on rules to set for their child while growing up. Nice one judge-Lester
ReplyDeletevery idiotic girl. mtcheeeewwwwwwwww
ReplyDeletevery idiotic girl. mtcheeeewwwwwwwww
ReplyDeleteWe are now abusing them but soon if care is not taken, we all will be a victim of this kinda situation . it starts with over pampering a child. When a parent will insult his/her child's school teacher for trying to take disciplinary actions against their child. Time shall tell
ReplyDeleteLinda this is a spoilt brat indeed,I love our African tradition,our culture irrespective of tribe.smh
ReplyDeleteShe should have sued in a Sharia court n see if she go fit sit down with that same yansh
ReplyDeleteSilly girl...come try am for naija!
ReplyDeleteUseless fool...bad and wicked child!..Ekwensu no n'ude mmadu!
ReplyDeleteWIZKID SLAPPED?
Nonsense. Biko let them ship her straight to naija for one week she will beg to be back
ReplyDeleteFirst of all......ungrateful and absolutely rotten child.
ReplyDeleteThere is no judgement as yet. The judge is only imploring the counsel (prosecuting lawyers for the girl) and no doubt the jury too to seriously consider the implication of this case on future cases if they successfully win/ rule in favour of the useless daughter!.
All of you barking make she come do am for Naija, una don finish whooping your politicians for looting billions of dollars from the people? All the Naija murderers, rapists, pedophiles, kidnappers, etc wey fill Naija nko? All these brats way dey knock people down in Lagos, Ibadan and other places with no regards no? Werent they raised by Nigerian parents on Nigerian soil with the so called Naija discipline? Make we hear one jare. Some of u go come hear and vomit evil stuff towards your fellow human beings, na who born una? Make una keep pretending and posing but make una no develop heart attack in the process.
ReplyDeleteKoboko dey settle matter in nigera
ReplyDeleteLord i pray, tht someday You grant me a child, to raise him/her in africa. Where kid's discipline is harvested, respect is manufactured and where kids have to endure the true meaning of a love hate treatment frm thr parents.
ReplyDeleteSeriously, an african kid raised abroad is soo difrnt frm the one raised in africa by a true african parent, wth no atoms of any white man's culture copy cats. Some of these kids will want to chop off thr parents heads, and the parent will let him or her do it!
The judge, is so wise wth loads of jurisprudence senses, bless
Objective point of view what are you saying? They told her that if she is going to leave in that house and under their care she had abide to by their rules and the rules of the house. She elected to live and then expects them to pay her bills notwithstanding. That's absolute poppycock! She is 18! In some families 18 is it, you are on your own henceforth! There is nothing be objective about! If you think you are grown, go ahead and be grown
ReplyDeleteshe's a spoilt brat
ReplyDeleteAnd whts wrong wf suin one's parents...Only bcos i'm Nigerian i'ld v sued dz ones dat calld demselves parents ova here for SEVERE CHILD ABUSE which z one of d fins dats causin my 366days severe depression!!!Asswipe pple yarnin nonsense here.......
ReplyDeleteeven as old as i am, i dare not look straight in my dads eye. not because i fear him, but i luv and respect him so much.
ReplyDeleteA Daniel has come to judge! I love the Judge's take on the girl's case. She's just being plain silly and a wet blanket. Her head must be set straight jare!
ReplyDelete